Judging at Decanter World Wine Awards in London or Decanter Asia Wine Awards in Hong Kong, whenever I wanted a second opinion on a wine, my go-to choice was Gerard Basset OBE, MS, MW, MBA, OIV MSc.

Gerard possessed the qualities that make for the ideal wine judge.

He was a Chairman of both those competitions, and myself Regional Chair for Asia in London and a Vice-Chair in Hong Kong.

Whether judging wine or people, the qualities that make for a good arbiter are not much different.

Gerard pops in on the Asia Panel at Decanter World Wine Awards 2016. Next to him is Peter Csizmadia-Honigh and to their right is Panel Chair CH’NG Poh Tiong
From left – Christelle Guibert, CH’NG Poh Tiong, Gerard Basset and Sarah Kemp. Photographed in London on 28 March 2017

Sensitivity

In the first place, a good jude needs to be sensitive. 

To be able to detect the intricacies of a wine (or the virtues or weaknesses of a person).

After detecting the characteristics of a wine (or human) we have to go on to interpret what we have detected.

Easier said than done.

Say, for example, you have picked up a lot of fruit or tannins in a wine. 

Are you able to determine if the fruit is primary, secondary or tertiary?

Knowing that will give you a clue as to whether the wine will continue to improve; have reached its optimum; or, start to go downhill.

If the tannins are powerful, are they holistic tannins from plant (stem) and fruit (skin and pip) or extraneous tannins from wood chips and oak? 

The trajectory of those different tannins will be different. 

Beyond knowing the differences of the tannins, are you able to project how the trajectories will end up?

Not Enough

Apart from possessing all those immense skills and talent, even more importantly (to me anyway), Gerard was incredibly humble.

In fact, he wasn’t so much humble as he was totally unaffected by it all.

People who are truly imbued with  humility, don’t actually even think they are humble (or otherwise).

They actually don’t know any different. 

My late friend was like that.

Gerard (right) was speaker at a dinner of Domaine Cazes, Rivesaltes, in Ming Court, Cordis Hong Kong on 8 September 2017. On the left is owner Emmanuel Cazes and next to him is Chef LI Yuet Faat 

Fairness

To be a good wine judge, it is not enough to be talented, knowledgeable and humble.

You need also to be fair.

I would go as far to say fairness is not an “extra” but a prerequisite.

Fairness to a wine usually works this way.

When not entirely sure about a wine, say, whether it should get Gold or Silver, or Bronze or kicked out of contention, the benefit of our doubt should always go to the wine.

Otherwise, the wine would be unfairly treated as a result of our doubt. 

The wine must have the better, fairer judgement.

This is the case in legal proceedings.

When, for example, we are not sure whether someone has stolen something or hurt another person, the doubt should not disadvantage or punish the accused but should, instead, set her or him free. 

It’s only fair.

A world of caution though. 

Being fair does not mean sitting on the fence and being wishy washy. 

When a wine is no good or is going downhill, be firm and decisive. 

Chuck it out. 

Gerard Basset with Henry Chang, Beverage Manager of China Club Hong Kong. Photographed on 5 September 2017

“Baggage”

Being fair also means not judging a wine with “baggage”.

Such judges are very painful. Practically useless.

At a private club which wine competition I have consulted since its inception more than 10 years ago, there was a judge (a member of the club) who never gave any red Bordeaux or Bordeaux blend Gold because they never came up to – his perceived and prejudiced – standard of the expensive Classified Growths he was used to drinking (and bragging about). 

I asked the club not to have him as a judge again.

Courage

A wine judge also needs courage.

Most wine judges forget that while they are judging wines, the wines are also judging us.

We need not only to be fair, sensitive, talented, and knowledgeable, but also to be brave. 

The vast majority of wine judges I have come across, are utterly afraid to give a Gold to a rosé.

These are judges who don’t usually sit in the rosé category or who hardly, if ever, drink rosé.

They judge rosé with the mindset of judging other wines (which, I may add, they are usually not very good at judging in the first place).

These insecure judges are afraid that if they award Gold to a rosé, other judges will think they are not “serious” judges.

They overcompensate for their inadequacy and insecurity. 

Get With It

If the rosé you are judging is as good as a rosé can be, what more does it need to be awarded Gold?

Put in another way, what way do you need to come to your senses?

If you were judging water, sugar cane or orange juice, judge them for what they are. Not something else.

You judge rosé as rosé, pizza as pizza, French fries as French fries and not try and compare them with something they are not. 

Do our job because the wine has done its.

Ch’ng Poh Tiong is acknowledged internationally as an authority on the wines of Bordeaux, China and Japan, particularly Koshu. He also love other wines, including the Southern Rhone, particularly Chateauneuf-du-Pape. Bordeaux remains his speciality and since 1999, he visits the region five to six times every year. Ch’ng Poh Tiong is South-East Asia’s most experienced wine judge having served on the same judging and tasting panels as Hugh Johnson, Steven Spurrier, Johnnie Hugel, Julian Brind MW, Gerard Basset MS & MW, Serena Sutcliffe MW, Jancis Robinson MW, John Avery MW, Neil Beckett, and Michael Brajkovich MW. He has also visited Cognac and Scotland a dozen times since more than 30 years ago. He was made a Keeper of the Quaich in 2012.

Comments(23)

  1. Lolita Browne 12 August 2022

    Hello

    Are you new to SEO and want to rank #1 on google this upcoming year?
    Here are 3 SEO strategies that will boost your rankings!

    #1: Focus on content
    #2: Optimize your title tag and your meta description
    #3: Use Google Search Console

    Subscribe here to learn more of my
    Secret SEO Tips & Trics https://zeep.ly/WkJgE?=631

    Thanks,
    Lolita Browne
    Please do not reply directly to this email!

    Reply
  2. TruffBarf 2 September 2022

    buy cialis uk There s no documented evidence of any major catastrophe with people taking these drugs recreationally, but it s not the sort of thing that s reported, he says

    Reply
  3. chilmip 4 September 2022

    what is priligy dapoxetine Additionally, there was no change of PVR between the groups 1

    Reply
  4. Adjudge 6 September 2022

    generic cialis 20mg The drug is known as generic Cialis and is known to act on a male body by increasing the flow of blood that goes to the penis of a man

    Reply
  5. treacle 8 September 2022

    To me Cialis Makes a man a better man where can i buy cialis on line When comparing patients who suffered from flushing, significant differences were found between the tadalafil and sildenafil groups fixed effects model OR 0

    Reply
  6. Packliark 11 September 2022

    Purpose Testosterone replacement therapy results in decreased serum gonadotropins hormones produced by the pituitary gland- LH and FSH- that jump-start testicular function and intratesticular testosterone inside the testicles , and impairs spermatogenesis sperm production , leading to azoospermia no viable sperm in 40 of patients. clomid pills for sale

    Reply
  7. frifuck 14 September 2022
    Reply
  8. অ্যালোপেসিয়া রোগের কারণে জেডা পিঙ্কেট স্মিথ নিজের মাথা প্রায় কামিয়ে.

    Reply
  9. Fromall 18 September 2022

    Crusted or Norwegian scabies was first described in patients with leprosy in Norway. doxycycline dosage for uti in adults We set 5 as the non- inferiority margin for the cure rate based on the findings from previous clinical trials 5, 6.

    Reply
  10. Enter the email address you signed up with and we’ll email you a reset link.

    Reply
  11. 1 esmer kızın amını sikip içine boşalma pornosu 0 görüntülenme.
    Esmer kızla beerg türk porno hd izle. Hemde hiç donmadan ve kesintisiz olarak izle
    ki tadı damağında kalsın tekrar dön aynı.

    Reply
  12. librego 9 October 2022

    levitra paroxetin neuraxpharm 40 mg Until the joint venture broke up on July 30, Uralkali used aformula for calculating Russian domestic prices based on itsexports lasix pill

    Reply
  13. Undelty 14 October 2022

    Both deny the charges and have tried to have the prosecutions adjourned or halted cialis vs viagra

    Reply
  14. Myrtle Chang 16 October 2022

    Hello

    You Need Help To Grow In Google And Drive More Traffic And Get You More Customers For wineguru.com.sg

    WE OFFERING QUALITY SEO SERVICES:
    ► Rank Higher Your Website In Google
    ► Rank Higher Video in Youtube & Google
    ► Rank Higher GMB In Google Maps
    ► High-Quality Organic Website Traffic
    ► We Create High-Quality Videos
    ► Content Text & Video for Your Website

    We Want To Prove To You That Our Services Work With Risk-Free
    WE OFFER FREE TEST=> https://zeep.ly/c4Fgr?=99862

    Thanks, SEObyAxy
    Please do not reply directly to this email!
    You can contact us from the contact page of the website!

    IF YOU NO LONGER WISH TO HEAR FROM US,
    PLEASE REPLY TO THIS EMAIL WITH:
    STOP EMAIL ME

    Reply
  15. groordesk 16 October 2022

    lasix to torsemide conversion H 2, Pd C, MeOH, 1 h, iii

    Reply
  16. Sotobre 25 October 2022

    Elias kEOoytZelXDfB 6 19 2022 buy ivermectin

    Reply
  17. thypelf 6 November 2022

    Larger reductions in the hazard ratio for recurrence have been reported in the sequencing and extended treatment regimens, but a proper evaluation of the overall impact on recurrence needs to account for the higher recurrence rates that occurred in the period before switching to an AI viagra priligy Thank you for all your helpful info

    Reply
  18. Deajerpex 6 November 2022

    tamoxifen breast cancer The table below shows a detailed patient history

    Reply
  19. pageada 7 November 2022

    al Baihaqi reported it cialis for sale in usa In the largest study in this population to date, a CALGB and Breast Cancer Intergroup study, 33 patients 65 and older with early stage breast cancer were randomly assigned to either standard treatment doxorubicin and cyclophosphamide AC for four cycles or cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and 5 fluorouracil CMF for six cycles or to an experimental arm of single agent capecitabine for six cycles

    Reply
  20. Swarcah 15 November 2022

    buy stromectol ireland Tianyu sx4 crossover study

    Reply
  21. wensawwax 16 November 2022

    I have very fond memories of both of them doxycycline for dogs Although not possessing the resolution of CT, MRI may have a special role in the localization of pheochromocytomas

    Reply
  22. Coolborie 22 November 2022

    how to take clomid If a pulled chest wall muscle is the source of your pain, your healthcare provider may recommend Tylenol acetaminophen or a nonsteroidal anti inflammatory drug NSAID to soothe your pain

    Reply
  23. HoaliaGor 23 November 2022

    lasix tinnitus It is thought that, until further clinical evidence comes up, aromatase inhibitors should be the initial hormonal therapy in postmenopausal early breast cancer patients

    Reply

Leave a comment